Minecraft is back in the spotlight over the chat reporting system controversy: in mid-November 2026, Mojang demanded that CurseForge and Modrinth take down two popular mods, No Chat Reports and No Chat Restrictions, arguing that these tools "weaken player safety and moderation" in a way that violates the EULA and Minecraft's usage guidelines. The mod author announced receiving a notice from CurseForge on November 16, 2026, saying the takedown is now just a formality, while Modrinth is so far refusing to comply with the request.
What these mods are and where they came from
No Chat Reports removes the cryptographic signature that Minecraft attaches to every chat message, a feature introduced alongside the chat reporting system in version 1.19.1 back in July 2022. Without that signature, a player's message can't be formally reported through Mojang's system, even if a server admin or another player wants to report it. No Chat Restrictions is a companion project that removes the client-side restrictions tied to that same moderation mechanism.
Both mods were created as a community response to the introduction of mandatory chat reporting, which has been controversial from the start due to privacy concerns around conversations, especially on private servers where Mojang doesn't actively monitor content anyway. Over time, other tools joined them, such as SecureChat, which encrypts messages between players.
Different reactions from CurseForge and Modrinth
The mod author stated that he received a notice from CurseForge agreeing to the takedown request just hours before publishing his own statement. The platform decided to "comply with takedown requests," which in practice meant both projects were close to inevitable removal from its repository.
Modrinth, which received a similar notice about a week earlier, took a completely different stance. A Modrinth representative, referred to in reports as Josh from the Modrinth team, stated directly: "We don't want Modrinth to become an enforcer of Microsoft's TOS." The platform also argued that Mojang's concerns were about what the project does rather than any clear copyright infringement, quoting the response: "Their concerns are primarily about what your project does, rather than any clear copyright infringement."
The mod author's stance
The creator of No Chat Reports and No Chat Restrictions has no intention of backing down without a fight. In his statement, he wrote that "they are not merely mods, they are ideas worth fighting for." For many players and server admins, these tools have become a symbol of resistance against moderation mechanisms they consider overly invasive toward private conversations.
It's worth remembering that the chat reporting system introduced in 2022 has been tied to waves of controversial bans from the very start. In June 2026, during the weekend starting June 20, accounts belonging to several content creators with millions of followers were banned, with some of them claiming they hadn't sent any chat messages or hadn't even played in weeks. Mojang said at the time that it was "actively investigating the situation," and restored access to those affected over the course of the weekend.
What this means for players
For players using Minecraft Java Edition, this matters in a very concrete way: if Modrinth eventually gives in to the pressure, a popular way of bypassing the chat reporting system will disappear from the main mod repositories, and the community will have to look for alternatives outside official platforms. On many Polish servers, where admins already police the culture of conversation themselves, mods like these were mainly used to reduce the risk of accidental bans caused by automatic, context-blind reports.
Mojang has not yet published any official, full statement explaining the legal basis for its demands to either platform, beyond a general reference to the EULA and usage guidelines. The situation remains ongoing: the key question is whether Modrinth will hold its ground or, under continued pressure, eventually remove the projects as well, just as CurseForge already did.